Authorship Criteria

PEPAKEM: Jurnal Hukum Tata Negara dan Politik Islam is committed to maintaining transparency, accountability, and academic integrity in the attribution of authorship. The journal recognizes authorship as both academic credit and responsibility for the scholarly content of a published work.

This policy establishes the criteria for authorship eligibility, author contributions, authorship order, corresponding author responsibilities, and the resolution of authorship-related concerns.

1. Authorship Eligibility

Authorship must be based on substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript.

PEPAKEM follows internationally recognized authorship principles, including the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), adapted to the context of legal and interdisciplinary scholarship.

To qualify as an author, an individual must meet all of the following criteria:

  1. Make a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the research; the collection, analysis, or interpretation of research materials; or the development of the scholarly argument.

  2. Participate in drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for important intellectual content.

  3. Review and approve the final version of the manuscript before submission or publication.

  4. Accept responsibility for the integrity and accuracy of their contributions and cooperate in addressing questions concerning the research.

Individuals who do not satisfy these criteria should not be listed as authors.

2. Substantial Scholarly Contributions

Recognized authorship contributions may include:

  • Developing research questions, theoretical frameworks, or legal arguments.

  • Designing normative, empirical, comparative, or interdisciplinary research methodologies.

  • Conducting legal analysis of legislation, judicial decisions, constitutional principles, legal doctrines, or Islamic political thought.

  • Collecting, analyzing, and interpreting relevant legal or empirical research data.

  • Developing original interpretations, conceptual frameworks, or theoretical contributions.

  • Drafting substantial sections of the manuscript or critically revising its intellectual content.

Routine administrative assistance, general supervision, funding acquisition, or technical support alone does not justify authorship unless accompanied by substantial intellectual contributions that satisfy the authorship criteria.

3. Authorship Order

The order of authors must be determined through mutual agreement among all contributors before manuscript submission.

The author listed first is generally expected to have made a significant contribution to the research and manuscript preparation.

The corresponding author is responsible for communication with the editorial team and coordination among all co-authors.

PEPAKEM does not prescribe a universal formula for determining authorship order. However, the order must fairly reflect the contributions and agreements of the authors.

Any disagreement regarding authorship order must be resolved by the authors before submission.

4. Corresponding Author Responsibilities

The corresponding author serves as the primary contact between the authors and the editorial team.

The corresponding author is responsible for:

  1. Ensuring that all listed authors meet the journal's authorship criteria.

  2. Obtaining approval from all authors for the manuscript's content and submission.

  3. Confirming that the manuscript has not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal.

  4. Providing accurate information regarding author identities, affiliations, and contact details.

  5. Coordinating responses to editorial decisions, reviewer comments, and revision requests.

  6. Communicating publication-related information to all co-authors.

  7. Ensuring that required declarations concerning conflicts of interest, funding, research ethics, and the use of generative artificial intelligence are accurately disclosed.

The corresponding author must not make substantive changes to the manuscript or authorship information without the knowledge and agreement of the relevant co-authors.

5. Author Contribution Statements

PEPAKEM encourages transparent disclosure of individual contributions, particularly for manuscripts involving multiple authors.

Where required by the editorial team, authors may be asked to provide an author contribution statement using appropriate contribution categories, including those reflected in the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT).

Relevant contribution categories may include:

  • Conceptualization

  • Methodology

  • Investigation

  • Formal Analysis

  • Data Curation

  • Writing – Original Draft

  • Writing – Review and Editing

  • Supervision

  • Project Administration

  • Funding Acquisition

Contribution statements must accurately represent the work performed by each author.

The acknowledgment of a contribution does not automatically establish authorship eligibility.

6. Changes in Authorship

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after manuscript submission must be supported by a clear explanation and written agreement from all affected authors.

Such requests must be submitted to the editorial team before publication.

The editorial team may request additional documentation to verify the legitimacy of the proposed changes.

Authorship changes will not be approved when they are intended to misrepresent contributions, conceal conflicts of interest, or provide inappropriate academic credit.

Requests for authorship changes after publication will be evaluated in accordance with the journal's publication ethics and correction policies.

7. Acknowledgment of Non-Author Contributions

Individuals who contribute to the research but do not meet the authorship criteria may be acknowledged in a separate acknowledgment section.

Such contributions may include:

  • Administrative or technical assistance.

  • Language editing or proofreading.

  • Research assistance that does not meet the authorship criteria.

  • Institutional or logistical support.

  • General academic advice or consultation.

Authors should obtain permission from individuals whose names are included in the acknowledgments.

Acknowledgment must not be used to imply endorsement of the manuscript by individuals or institutions without their consent.

8. Generative Artificial Intelligence and Authorship

Generative artificial intelligence tools, including large language models and other AI-assisted systems, must not be listed as authors or co-authors.

Authorship requires intellectual accountability, ethical responsibility, and the ability to approve and defend scholarly work, which cannot be assigned to AI systems.

Human authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and reliability of all manuscript content, including materials developed with AI assistance.

Any substantive use of generative AI in manuscript preparation must be disclosed in accordance with the journal's Plagiarism & Generative AI Policy.

AI-generated content must be critically reviewed and verified by the authors, particularly when it involves legal interpretations, references, legislation, judicial decisions, or scholarly citations.

The use of AI tools does not reduce or replace the responsibilities of human authors.

9. Prevention of Authorship Misconduct

PEPAKEM does not tolerate unethical authorship practices, including:

  • Gift Authorship: Listing individuals who have not made qualifying scholarly contributions.

  • Guest Authorship: Including individuals primarily because of their academic reputation, institutional position, or professional influence.

  • Ghost Authorship: Omitting individuals who made qualifying intellectual contributions to the manuscript.

  • Coercive Authorship: Requiring the inclusion of an individual as an author through institutional authority or other forms of pressure.

  • Misrepresentation of Contributions: Providing inaccurate information regarding the actual roles of authors or contributors.

Suspected authorship misconduct may be investigated by the editorial team in accordance with the journal's publication ethics procedures.

10. Authorship Disputes and Resolution

Authors are expected to resolve disagreements concerning authorship eligibility, order, or contribution through transparent communication and mutual agreement.

If an authorship dispute is reported during the editorial process, PEPAKEM may temporarily suspend manuscript evaluation or publication until the matter has been adequately addressed.

The editorial team may request supporting documentation or refer the dispute to the authors' affiliated institutions when appropriate.

The journal does not ordinarily determine the relative intellectual contributions of disputing individuals without sufficient evidence.

Editorial decisions concerning disputed manuscripts will prioritize academic integrity, fairness, transparency, and the reliability of the scholarly record.

11. Author Accountability and Policy Compliance

All authors are collectively responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts comply with the journal's academic and ethical standards.

Each author must be able to identify their own contributions and cooperate in resolving questions concerning the integrity of the research.

Authors must ensure that their manuscripts are original, appropriately referenced, and free from plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, and other forms of research misconduct.

All authors are required to comply with the journal's Author Guidelines, Publication Ethics, Plagiarism & Generative AI Policy, and other relevant editorial policies.

PEPAKEM reserves the right to request authorship clarification, supporting documentation, or corrective action when concerns arise regarding authorship eligibility or academic integrity.

Through this policy, PEPAKEM seeks to promote responsible authorship practices and maintain public confidence in scholarly publications concerning constitutional law, Islamic political studies, governance, and related legal disciplines.