ADDITIONAL MENU
ABOUT THE JOURNAL
OWNERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT INFORMATION
PEPAKEM: Jurnal Hukum Tata Negara dan Politik Islam recognizes post-publication discussion as an essential component of scholarly communication, academic accountability, and the continuous development of legal and political knowledge.
The journal encourages constructive academic dialogue concerning published articles, particularly those addressing constitutional law, state administrative law, legal politics and legislation, politics and government, Islamic constitutional thought, and related interdisciplinary issues.
This policy establishes the principles and procedures for scholarly discussion, critical commentary, author responses, and the handling of concerns raised after publication.
Post-publication discussion aims to strengthen the quality, transparency, and reliability of published scholarly research.
PEPAKEM welcomes academically grounded comments, critical evaluations, alternative interpretations, and constructive responses to published articles.
Such discussions may address:
Theoretical arguments and conceptual frameworks.
Research methodology and analytical approaches.
Interpretation of constitutional provisions, legislation, and judicial decisions.
Application of Islamic legal and political principles.
Accuracy and relevance of research findings.
Implications for public policy, governance, and constitutional development.
Other substantive matters relevant to the journal's focus and scope.
Post-publication discussion should contribute to scholarly understanding rather than serve as a platform for personal disputes, political campaigning, or unsupported allegations.
All post-publication discussions must uphold the principles of academic integrity, objectivity, transparency, professionalism, and mutual respect.
Comments and criticisms should be based on verifiable evidence, relevant scholarly references, sound legal reasoning, or clearly articulated theoretical arguments.
PEPAKEM supports intellectual diversity and recognizes that differences in legal interpretation, constitutional theory, and Islamic political thought are legitimate elements of academic discourse.
However, scholarly disagreement must be expressed respectfully and must not involve defamatory statements, personal attacks, discriminatory language, or deliberate misrepresentation of an author's arguments.
Readers, researchers, practitioners, and other interested parties may submit comments, questions, or concerns regarding published articles through the journal's official editorial contact channels.
Submissions should clearly identify the article being discussed, including its title, author or authors, publication details, and relevant sections.
Contributors are encouraged to provide a concise explanation of their observations, supported by appropriate evidence or references.
The editorial team may request additional clarification or supporting documentation before considering a submission.
The submission of a comment does not automatically guarantee its publication or public display.
The editorial team is responsible for evaluating post-publication comments and determining whether they are appropriate for further consideration.
The assessment may consider:
Relevance to the published article and the journal's scholarly scope.
Clarity and academic significance of the issues raised.
Adequacy of supporting evidence and references.
Compliance with academic ethics and professional communication standards.
Potential implications for the accuracy or integrity of the published scholarly record.
The editorial team may decline to consider comments containing personal attacks, unsupported accusations, irrelevant material, or content that violates applicable ethical or legal standards.
Where appropriate, substantive scholarly comments may be referred to the original authors or independent experts for further assessment.
Authors of published articles may be invited to respond to substantive comments, criticisms, or questions concerning their work.
Author responses should address the academic issues raised and provide appropriate explanations, supporting evidence, or additional references where necessary.
PEPAKEM encourages authors to engage constructively with legitimate scholarly criticism and to acknowledge errors when they are identified.
Authors should avoid personal arguments or responses that do not directly address the academic substance of the discussion.
The editorial team may facilitate communication between contributors and authors to ensure that the discussion remains balanced, professional, and academically relevant.
PEPAKEM recognizes that constitutional law, political governance, and Islamic political thought often involve competing interpretations, theoretical perspectives, and normative positions.
Differences of opinion regarding constitutional principles, legislative policies, judicial reasoning, state institutions, or Islamic political concepts do not necessarily constitute errors or research misconduct.
The journal distinguishes legitimate academic disagreement from demonstrable factual inaccuracies, methodological deficiencies, or violations of publication ethics.
Scholarly debates should be evaluated on the strength of their arguments and supporting evidence rather than on the institutional affiliation, political orientation, or personal identity of the contributors.
When post-publication discussion identifies possible factual errors, inaccurate citations, methodological problems, undisclosed conflicts of interest, plagiarism, data fabrication, or other concerns affecting the integrity of a published article, the editorial team may initiate an appropriate assessment.
Depending on the nature and seriousness of the issue, the journal may consider:
Requesting clarification or supporting documentation from the authors.
Consulting relevant reviewers or independent experts.
Publishing a correction or clarification.
Issuing an editorial notice or expression of concern when warranted.
Initiating a retraction procedure in cases involving serious and substantiated problems.
Any corrective action will be handled in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Retraction & Correction policies.
Academic criticism alone does not constitute sufficient grounds for retracting an article.
PEPAKEM is committed to handling post-publication discussions fairly, consistently, and independently.
Editorial decisions concerning comments, author responses, corrections, or other actions must be based on scholarly relevance, credible evidence, and applicable publication ethics standards.
The editorial team seeks to avoid conflicts of interest and inappropriate influence when evaluating post-publication concerns.
Where a matter involves an editor or another individual with a potential conflict of interest, the assessment should be handled by an appropriate editorial representative without that conflict.
Information submitted during the assessment of post-publication concerns will be handled responsibly, particularly when it involves confidential correspondence, unpublished evidence, personal information, or allegations of research misconduct.
The editorial team may communicate with authors, reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties when necessary to assess a concern.
Confidential information should not be disclosed beyond what is reasonably necessary for the evaluation and resolution of the matter.
Public communication concerning post-publication concerns should be accurate, proportionate, and consistent with the journal's ethical responsibilities.
PEPAKEM views post-publication discussion as an opportunity to improve scholarly understanding and strengthen the reliability of academic publications.
The journal encourages readers and authors to engage in responsible intellectual exchange, recognize legitimate differences of interpretation, and contribute to the development of legal and political scholarship.
Through this policy, PEPAKEM seeks to promote a transparent, inclusive, and accountable scholarly environment while safeguarding editorial independence and the integrity of the published academic record.
OWNERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT INFORMATION
https://jurnalaksa.stsrdvisi.ac.id/
https://e-journal.lrpsu.or.id/
https://conference.inwecna.org/
https://actamonetaria.am-journal.id/
https://conferences.iaipibandung.ac.id/
https://jurnal.contradixie.id/
https://repositorio.fdci.edu.br/
https://jet.royalacademiapublishing.com/